Analyze criticism of the electoral college

But the impact of the college on presidential elections is far greater and more controversial than its brief life indicates. Each state has a number of electors equal to the number of its U. Currently, the Electoral College includes electors, for the total number of congressional members, and three who represent Washington, D. On the Monday following the second Wednesday in December, the electors of each state meet in their respective state capitals to officially cast their votes for president and vice president.

Analyze criticism of the electoral college

Today, far from being considered perfect or excellent, the Electoral College is criticized for being somehow undemocratic. Is this criticism justified? Ashland University Professor David Foster addresses that criticism.

Presidential elections often prompt criticism of the system we use to appoint a chief executive. For if re-election depended on a known body of men — a legislature, for example — the president might sacrifice his duty to please that body.

Analyze criticism of the electoral college

Thus, the method described in the Constitution aims at a calm, thoughtful choice unaffected by domestic disorder and the machinations of foreign governments. At the same time, because it is intended to combine dependence on the people of America with meaningful input from those with a deep knowledge of politics, it aims at a wise choice the people will support.

In Federalist 68, Hamilton explains how all these advantages, discussed apparently in ascending order of importance, are achieved through the system of electors. The Jefferson-Burr deadlock of revealed the problem of having electors make two votes without distinguishing President and Vice-President.

Other oversights were remedied in the 20th and 25th Amendmentsbut none of these changes fundamentally altered the system. Despite the great transformation in the country sincethe Electoral College system has proved remarkably flexible and stable, delivering appointments that have been widely accepted as legitimate by the American people for two and a quarter centuries.

I just felt that you could never replicate the classroom experience.

50 Documents That Tell America’s Story

With a broadband internet connection, an ordinary computer or laptop, and a standard web browser, students and the instructor can see and hear one another, live and in real time. There is lots of back and forth dialogue.

Sikkenga, about his recent Live Online course on the Supreme Court. Technological glitches are rare. The Supreme Court has profoundly affected the course of American history, yet few citizens understand how it operates. Teachers need a clear understanding, since important moments in American history are often heralded by Supreme Court decisions.

Some textbooks cover this decision in a way that is not very accurate; others in a way that is accurate but incomplete. The average citizen reacts to a Supreme Court decision as he would to a legislative or executive action, measuring it against his own sense of fairness.

But the Court measures the law against the Constitution. It is important to understand how this works, though.

Their job is to decide legal cases that come before them. There are lots of other courts around the world who assess the constitutionality of law before it is passed.

The Court assesses the constitutionality of laws after citizens and communities have already lived with it in practice.

Board of Education, the Court overturned an understanding of the Fourteenth Amendment that had been in place since the ruling in Plessy v. Ferguson and after intervening decades of Jim Crow laws and practices. Politics play a role at times, as justices decide which cases to hear.The Electoral College was created by the framers of the U.S.

Constitution as a compromise for the presidential election process. At the time, some politicians believed a purely popular election was too reckless and would give too much voting power to highly populated areas in which people were familiar with a presidential candidate.

Analyze criticism of the electoral college

saw two minor, yet somewhat interesting, additions to the "Electoral College story": on 6 January, as the Electoral Vote was being announced and tallied in Joint Session of Congress, the provisions of the Act regarding the handling of objections to the counting of a State's Electoral .

Thoroughly revised and updated, with an extensive analysis of the election, this book remains the best analysis of the Electoral College for both students and general readers.

“The best book available on the electoral nationwidesecretarial.coms: 7.

The Electoral College, while controversial in some respects, probably isn't going anywhere because it is part of the Constitution, and abolishing it would require support from more states than we. Tally of the Electoral College Vote The Electoral College is one of the more difficult parts of the American electoral process to understand. While election of the president and vice-president was provided for in Article II, Section 1, Clauses 2, 3, and 4 of the U.S. Constitution, the process today has moved substantially away from the. As in the past, however, a majority (55%) supports changing the way presidents are elected so that the candidate who receives the most total votes nationwide – rather than a majority in the Electoral College – wins the presidency.

The Electoral College distorts presidential campaigns, disenfranchises voters and drives partisanship, Stanford scholars say.

They suggest constitutional reforms to adopt a single national popular.

Expert Answers

As in the past, however, a majority (55%) supports changing the way presidents are elected so that the candidate who receives the most total votes nationwide – rather than a majority in the Electoral College – wins the presidency.

Reform Options for the Electoral College. Reform Options for the Electoral College and the Election of the US President (also, be sure to visit our page of frequently asked questions about reform): Direct Election with Instant Runoff Voting.

What are the advantages and disadvantages of an electoral college system? | Yahoo Answers